• About Us

    About Us

    Californians Against Assisted Suicide is a coalition of disability rights, healthcare, civil rights and patient advocacy organizations dedicated to preventing legalization of doctor assisted suicide in California.

    Read More
  • Contact Us

    Contact Us

    For press/media inquiries, or for more information about our organization, email us or visit our Facebook or Twitter pages.

    Read More
  • In Their Own Words

    In Their Own Words

    Leaders from the disability rights, civil rights and medical communities speak out against assisted suicide. View these video testimonies outlining the numerous problems and issues that arising from assisted suicide legalization.

    Read More
  • Join Us

    Join Us

    Stay updated on the latest news regarding this important issue and be part of the effort to make sure assisted suicide does not come to California.

    Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Wednesday, 09 September 2015 14:28

San Jose Mercury News: Oregon assisted suicide law no model for California

Rate this item
(0 votes)

sj merc logo

September 3, 2015

Many advocates of a California law allowing doctor-assisted suicide for terminally ill individuals claim that Oregon's law offers a suitable model. But there are serious problems with the legislation in Oregon and many documented cases of abuse.

 

I have evaluated and treated thousands of patients who wanted to end their life.  A request to die is nearly always a cry for help.  Among terminally ill individuals, this request is associated with depression in 59% of cases.  And yet, alarmingly, in Oregon less than 5% of individuals who have died by assisted suicide were ever referred for psychiatric consultation to rule out the most common causes of suicidal thinking.   Consider the case of Oregonian Michael Freeland, a man with a 43-year history of intermittent depression and suicide attempts prior to his diagnosed medical illness.  The doctor who prescribed him the deadly drug did not deem it necessary to refer him for psychiatric consultation.  The proposed law in California likewise does not require psychiatric screening.  

We’ve seen in Oregon the problem of doctor-shopping, and cases of individuals being pressured by family members.  Consider the case of 85-year-old Kate Cheney: her physician and a consulting psychiatrist declined to prescribe the life-ending medication, judging that she lacked capacity due to her dementia, and documenting that the patient’s daughter appeared “somewhat coercive”.  Nevertheless, a managed care insurance company found her another doctor who did prescribe the lethal drug.  The Oregon Health Division has publicly stated that it has no resources and no authority to monitor or investigate such reported cases of abuse.

Since very few practicing physicians are willing to participate in writing these prescriptions, where it is legalized doctor assisted death becomes a marginalized cottage industry: in Oregon a small number of physicians write a disproportionately large number of the prescriptions.  Consider the case of the first woman to die by assisted suicide in Oregon: her physician and a second consulting doctor both refused to end her life because they judged that her request was motivated by untreated clinical depression.  The assisted suicide advocacy group Compassion and Choices got involved and referred the woman to their preferred doctor who provided the deadly drug.

Despite the inadequate system of monitoring and reporting in Oregon, the data we do have paints a distressing picture.  After suicide rates had declined in the 1990s, they rose dramatically in Oregon between 2000 and 2010, in the years following the legalization of assisted suicide in 1997.  By 2010 suicide rates were 35% higher in Oregon than the national average.  A rigorous study by David Albert Jones of Oxford University to be published next month controls for other factors that could account for this rise: this research demonstrates that the permissive assisted suicide laws have led to at least a 6% rise in overall suicide rates in Washington & Oregon. 

Suicide is among the health-related behaviors that tend to spread from person-to-person through social networks—up to three degrees of separation.  We know also that publicized cases lead to clusters of copycat cases.  A Swiss study in 2003, for example, indicated evidence for suicide contagion following media reports of doctor-assisted suicide.  Furthermore, the law itself is a teacher.  These laws communicate the message that under especially difficult circumstances, some lives are not worth living.  This message will be heard not only by those with a terminal illness, but by any person struggling with the temptation to end his or her own life.

The Oregon law permitting physician-assisted suicide does not offer a good model for California to follow.

Aaron Kheriaty, M.D., is associate professor of psychiatry and director of the Medical Ethics Program at UC Irvine School of Medicine.

Source:  San Jose Mercury News

Last modified on Monday, 21 September 2015 07:12

Search

We Oppose Assisted Suicide

  • Access to Independence – San Diego
  • American Disabled for Attendant Programs Today – Northern California (ADAPT)
  • American Disabled for Attendant Programs Today – Southern California (ADAPT)
  • Alliance of Catholic Healthcare
  • American Academy of Medical Ethics (AAME)
  • American College of Physicians – American Society of Internal Medicine
  • American College of Pediatricians
  • American Medical Association
  • American Nursing Association
  • Association of Northern California Oncologists (ANCO)
  • Association of Programs for Rural Independent Living (APRIL)
  • Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN)
  • Berkeley Commission on Disability
  • California Catholic Conference
  • California Chapter of TASH (CalTASH)
  • California Disability Alliance (CDA)
  • California Family Alliance
  • California Family Council
  • California Foundation for Independent Living Centers (CFILC)
  • California Latino Medical Association
  • California Nurses for Ethical Standards (CNES)
  • California ProLife Council
  • California Right to Life Education Fund
  • California State Council on Developmental Disabilities
  • Californians for Disability Rights (CDR)
  • Catholics for the Common Good
  • Center for Independence of Individuals with Disabilities (CID)
  • Christian Medical and Dental Association
  • Coalition for Concerned Medical Professionals
  • Communities Actively Living Independents and Free (CALIF)
  • Crusade for Life
  • De La Salle Institute
  • Disability Rights Center
  • Disability Rights Education & Defense Fund (DREDF)
  • Disability Rights Enforcement Education Services (DREES)
  • Disability Section of the American Public Health Association
  • FREED, Center for Independent Living
  • Hispanics for Life
  • Independent Living Center of Southern California (ILCSC)
  • Independent Living Resource Center San Francisco (ILRCSF)
  • Independent Living Services of Northern California (ILSNC)
  • International Life Services
  • Joni and Friends
  • Justice for All (JFA)
  • La Raza Roundtable of Santa Clara County
  • League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
  • Life Priority Network
  • Life Legal Defense Foundation
  • Medical Oncology Association of Southern California (MOASC)
  • National Council on Disability
  • National Council on Independent Living (NCIL)
  • National Spinal Cord Injury Association
  • Not Dead Yet – California Chapter
  • Not Dead Yet (NDY)
  • Oakland Mayors Commission on Human Relations
  • Patients Rights Council
  • Physicians for Compassionate Care
  • Placer Independent Resource Services, Inc.
  • Pro-Life America
  • Right to Life League of Southern California
  • San Mateo County, CA
  • Scholl Institute of Bioethics
  • Second Thoughts, People Living with Disabilities Opposing Assisted Suicide
  • Southern California Cancer Pain Initiative
  • TASH
  • The Arc of California
  • The California Catholic Conference
  • The Center for Bioethics and Culture Network (CBC Network)
  • The Oaks Group
  • West Coast Pro Life
  • Western Service Workers Association
  • World Association of Persons with Disabilities (WAPD)