• About Us

    About Us

    Californians Against Assisted Suicide is a coalition of disability rights, healthcare, civil rights and patient advocacy organizations dedicated to preventing legalization of doctor assisted suicide in California.

    Read More
  • Contact Us

    Contact Us

    For press/media inquiries, or for more information about our organization, email us or visit our Facebook or Twitter pages.

    Read More
  • In Their Own Words

    In Their Own Words

    Leaders from the disability rights, civil rights and medical communities speak out against assisted suicide. View these video testimonies outlining the numerous problems and issues that arising from assisted suicide legalization.

    Read More
  • Join Us

    Join Us

    Stay updated on the latest news regarding this important issue and be part of the effort to make sure assisted suicide does not come to California.

    Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Thursday, 26 February 2015 23:41

The Sacramento Bee: Assisted suicide helps very few, endangers more

Rate this item
(1 Vote)

SacBeeLogo

BY LAURA PETRILLO

02/25/2015

The U.S. health care system does many things well, but it is becoming increasingly clear that helping people die peacefully is not one of them. Many people spend their last months of life in emergency rooms, infusion centers or intensive care units, receiving interventions that not only fail to prolong life, but instead increase suffering for both the dying and their survivors.

There has been a recent swell of interest in physician aid in dying – giving doctors the power to prescribe lethal medications to terminally ill patients so they can end their lives at the time of their choosing. Brittany Maynard, a young woman with a fatal brain tumor, popularized this idea when she used Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act to end her life. In response to the interest she generated, states across the country, including California, are considering legislation to legalize doctor-assisted suicide.

As a palliative care physician who focuses on improving the quality of life of seriously ill and dying patients, I wholeheartedly agree that we are at a crossroads, and it is time to fight for better care at the end of life. But aid in dying should not be the focus of the battle cry, because it actually meets the needs of very few and endangers many more. 

Most people who avail themselves of assisted suicide in Oregon and Washington are educated, white and affluent. They have access to good end-of-life care and have resources to get help at home, and yet still crave the ability to exert control over their exact moment of death. Their numbers are very small, accounting for less than 1 percent of all deaths in Oregon in 2014.

By contrast, most dying people I meet do not want to acknowledge – let alone plan for – the approaching end of their lives. As a result, many miss out on supportive care that might improve the quality of the time they have left. Some patients hesitate to take medication to alleviate pain for fear it might hasten their death, or wait to seek services such as hospice because they think that would signal “giving up.” 

There is often racial and socioeconomic variation to this – the more marginalized patients are, the more they will grasp at any treatment offered to them, no matter how uncomfortable or expensive it is, or how unlikely it is to help. Making assisted suicide an acceptable medical practice would unequivocally alter the patient-doctor relationship and endanger trust in medicine at the end of life, driving away those who need it most. 

Many patients have asked me to hasten their deaths, but when we explore this feeling, there is often something else under the surface. They may need help with depression or pain, or they feel like a burden to their caregivers. In a world where physician-assisted death is ubiquitous, busy or untrained doctors could take requests for aid in dying at face value and provide means to end someone’s life instead of trying to restore a quality of life that is worth living to them. Legalizing aid in dying implicitly condones the idea that someone can be a burden or that a life can lose its value, and could subtly coerce the frail and infirm to end their lives.

A bill in the state Senate would legalize doctor-assisted suicide, and a lawsuit was filed by a group of patients and doctors against the state to overturn a statute that prohibits it. Though I understand the frustration that spurred this movement and believe strongly in respecting patient autonomy, I also believe that there are many things we can do to restore dignity to the dying process that do not involve lethal medications, such as reforming hospice care and being more thoughtful about end-of-life treatment. 

Doctor-assisted suicide inappropriately channels a completely justified outrage against our broken system into a dangerous public policy that puts vulnerable people at risk.

Laura Petrillo is a hospice and palliative medicine fellow at the University of California, San Francisco.

Source:  The Sacramento Bee

Last modified on Monday, 21 September 2015 07:22

Search

We Oppose Assisted Suicide

  • Access to Independence – San Diego
  • American Disabled for Attendant Programs Today – Northern California (ADAPT)
  • American Disabled for Attendant Programs Today – Southern California (ADAPT)
  • Alliance of Catholic Healthcare
  • American Academy of Medical Ethics (AAME)
  • American College of Physicians – American Society of Internal Medicine
  • American College of Pediatricians
  • American Medical Association
  • American Nursing Association
  • Association of Northern California Oncologists (ANCO)
  • Association of Programs for Rural Independent Living (APRIL)
  • Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN)
  • Berkeley Commission on Disability
  • California Catholic Conference
  • California Chapter of TASH (CalTASH)
  • California Disability Alliance (CDA)
  • California Family Alliance
  • California Family Council
  • California Foundation for Independent Living Centers (CFILC)
  • California Latino Medical Association
  • California Nurses for Ethical Standards (CNES)
  • California ProLife Council
  • California Right to Life Education Fund
  • California State Council on Developmental Disabilities
  • Californians for Disability Rights (CDR)
  • Catholics for the Common Good
  • Center for Independence of Individuals with Disabilities (CID)
  • Christian Medical and Dental Association
  • Coalition for Concerned Medical Professionals
  • Communities Actively Living Independents and Free (CALIF)
  • Crusade for Life
  • De La Salle Institute
  • Disability Rights Center
  • Disability Rights Education & Defense Fund (DREDF)
  • Disability Rights Enforcement Education Services (DREES)
  • Disability Section of the American Public Health Association
  • FREED, Center for Independent Living
  • Hispanics for Life
  • Independent Living Center of Southern California (ILCSC)
  • Independent Living Resource Center San Francisco (ILRCSF)
  • Independent Living Services of Northern California (ILSNC)
  • International Life Services
  • Joni and Friends
  • Justice for All (JFA)
  • La Raza Roundtable of Santa Clara County
  • League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
  • Life Priority Network
  • Life Legal Defense Foundation
  • Medical Oncology Association of Southern California (MOASC)
  • National Council on Disability
  • National Council on Independent Living (NCIL)
  • National Spinal Cord Injury Association
  • Not Dead Yet – California Chapter
  • Not Dead Yet (NDY)
  • Oakland Mayors Commission on Human Relations
  • Patients Rights Council
  • Physicians for Compassionate Care
  • Placer Independent Resource Services, Inc.
  • Pro-Life America
  • Right to Life League of Southern California
  • San Mateo County, CA
  • Scholl Institute of Bioethics
  • Second Thoughts, People Living with Disabilities Opposing Assisted Suicide
  • Southern California Cancer Pain Initiative
  • TASH
  • The Arc of California
  • The California Catholic Conference
  • The Center for Bioethics and Culture Network (CBC Network)
  • The Oaks Group
  • West Coast Pro Life
  • Western Service Workers Association
  • World Association of Persons with Disabilities (WAPD)